Have you ever walked away from an argument absolutely convinced you were right, yet equally certain you hadn’t changed the other person’s mind?
Perhaps you presented compelling evidence, anticipated every objection, and explained your position with remarkable clarity. By the end of the conversation, you felt confident that your argument was stronger.
And yet, somehow, the other person seemed even more committed to their original position.
It’s a familiar experience, particularly in a culture where disagreements about politics, religion, and social issues increasingly become contests to determine who is right.
But I wonder whether we’re sometimes asking the wrong question.
Instead of asking whether we won the argument, perhaps we should ask whether the conversation accomplished anything worthwhile.
Because being right and being persuasive are not necessarily the same thing.
Why Facts Aren’t Always Enough
During my graduate studies in psychology, one of the subjects I found particularly interesting was the relationship between our beliefs, emotions, and behavior.
We tend to imagine that people form opinions by gathering information, evaluating the evidence, and arriving at reasonable conclusions.
Sometimes that’s exactly what happens.
But our beliefs are also influenced by personal experiences, relationships, emotions, and the communities with which we identify.
Psychologists use the term psychological reactance to describe the resistance people may experience when they perceive that their freedom to make their own choices is being threatened.
In other words, the harder we push someone toward a particular conclusion, the more motivated they may become to defend their independence.
This doesn’t happen in every disagreement, and it doesn’t mean facts are unimportant. But it helps explain why an argument that seems perfectly reasonable to one person may provoke resistance in another.
If our goal is genuinely to persuade, that distinction deserves our attention.
The Difference Between Listening and Waiting to Speak
One of the habits I’ve noticed in difficult conversations is how quickly listening can become little more than preparation for our next response.
While the other person is speaking, we’re already identifying weaknesses in their argument or preparing the point we believe will finally convince them.
We may hear every word without making much effort to understand what they’re actually trying to communicate.
But there’s a meaningful difference between listening to respond and listening to understand.
One approach from psychology that illustrates this distinction is motivational interviewing.
Originally developed to help people work through behavioral change, motivational interviewing emphasizes collaboration, thoughtful questions, and respect for an individual’s autonomy.
Rather than simply telling someone what they should believe or do, the approach encourages people to examine their own motivations, concerns, and reasons for change.
It isn’t a technique that guarantees agreement, nor is every disagreement an appropriate setting for a therapeutic method. But the underlying principle has broader relevance.
People may be more willing to consider an unfamiliar perspective when they don’t feel that their independence is being threatened.
Understanding someone’s position doesn’t require agreeing with it.
Sometimes that understanding creates an opportunity for persuasion. Other times, it simply creates an opportunity for a more respectful relationship.
Both can be worthwhile.
Persuasion Requires More Than Confidence
There’s an important distinction between trying to persuade someone and trying to defeat them.
Winning an argument often involves demonstrating that the other person’s reasoning is flawed or that our evidence is stronger.
Persuasion asks a different question: What might help this person genuinely reconsider their perspective?
That requires more than a well-constructed argument. It also requires humility.
Psychologists sometimes describe intellectual humility as recognizing that our knowledge and beliefs have limitations and that we may be mistaken about particular questions.
Intellectual humility doesn’t require us to abandon our convictions or treat every opinion as equally credible.
It means being willing to acknowledge uncertainty, consider new evidence, and recognize that even deeply held beliefs deserve thoughtful examination.
This can be particularly challenging when our beliefs are closely connected to our identity or community.
But I would suggest that people who are secure in their convictions should be especially capable of listening to opposing perspectives without feeling threatened by them.
We may discover that part of our own argument needs reconsideration. Or we may recognize that the disagreement involves legitimate differences in values rather than a simple misunderstanding of facts.
Neither outcome should be considered a failure.
What Does Scripture Say About Persuasion?
For Christians, the way we engage in disagreement should be more than a matter of communication strategy.
It should reflect the character we aspire to demonstrate.
James 1:19 encourages believers to be quick to listen, slow to speak, and slow to become angry.
Proverbs 18:13 warns against answering before listening.
And Colossians 4:6 encourages speech characterized by grace and wisdom.
These passages don’t suggest that Christians should avoid difficult conversations or remain silent about deeply held convictions.
They suggest that how we communicate matters.
There is a temptation, particularly when discussing matters of faith, to assume that the importance of our message excuses the manner in which we deliver it.
But if our words communicate contempt, impatience, or superiority, we may undermine the very principles we’re trying to defend.
A person may forget the details of our argument while remembering how we made them feel.
And although kindness doesn’t guarantee persuasion, disrespect can create obstacles that even the strongest reasoning struggles to overcome.
When Changing Someone’s Mind Isn’t the Goal
Perhaps one of the most important things to recognize is that not every disagreement needs to end with someone changing their mind.
There are conversations in which the most meaningful outcome is a better understanding of another person’s perspective.
There are others in which preserving a relationship is more important than resolving a particular disagreement.
And there are circumstances in which a conversation reveals that we need to reconsider something ourselves.
This doesn’t mean truth is relative or that every position deserves equal acceptance.
It means that our responsibility in a conversation may extend beyond convincing someone that we’re correct.
We can communicate clearly, challenge ideas respectfully, and remain committed to what we believe without making agreement the measure of success.
A Better Measure of a Good Conversation
I don’t believe we need fewer convictions or less willingness to defend them.
We need people who care enough about what they believe to communicate those beliefs thoughtfully.
That means asking better questions, listening more carefully, and recognizing that the people we disagree with are more than the positions they hold.
It also means accepting that persuasion is not something we can demand from another person.
We can offer evidence, explain our reasoning, and invite consideration. But we cannot force someone to understand or agree.
Perhaps the better question after a difficult conversation isn’t simply whether we made our point.
It’s whether we created an opportunity for understanding.
Being right may determine the strength of our argument. How we treat others while making it reveals something about our character.
And sometimes, the most persuasive thing we can do is demonstrate that we’re willing to listen.